On November 16, 2026, the U.S. Supreme Court declined to hear Novotny v. Moore, a challenge to Maryland’s restrictions on carrying firearms in many public places. Justice Clarence Thomas agreed with that decision but issued a separate statement expressing serious doubts that many of those “sensitive places” laws fit the nation’s historical tradition of firearm regulation. He called for the Court to examine the issue in a narrower future case. Maryland’s rules remain in place for now. Gun-rights groups called the statement encouraging. State officials and lower-court judges have so far treated the restrictions as valid.
![]() |
| Clarence Thomas – The Oyez Project |
What the Supreme Court Did and Did Not Do
The Court denied the petition for certiorari without a signed opinion from the majority. That means the Fourth Circuit’s earlier ruling stands. In January 2026 the appeals court had upheld most of Maryland’s 2023 restrictions on carrying guns in locations such as public transit, state parks and forests, healthcare facilities, places of amusement, and establishments that sell alcohol for on-site consumption. It rejected one part of the law that required express permission before carrying on private property open to the public.
Thomas wrote a four-page statement respecting the denial. He agreed the broad challenge was not the right vehicle because each restricted location would require its own historical analysis. He then added: “I harbor serious doubts that our Nation’s historical tradition of firearm regulation supports many of these sweeping restrictions.” He continued: “In an appropriate case, this Court should consider whether particular sensitive-place laws are consistent with the right to public carry.”
The official docket is available here: Novotny v. Moore, No. 25-1324. Thomas’s statement is published as a PDF on the Court’s site: Statement of Justice Thomas.
Gateway Pundit covered the development the same day: Justice Clarence Thomas Puts Democrat-Controlled States on Notice Over Sweeping Gun Bans.
What Maryland’s Law Actually Restricts
Maryland enacted the measures in 2023, shortly after the Supreme Court’s 2022 decision in New York State Rifle & Pistol Association v. Bruen. Bruen held that the Second Amendment protects the right to carry a handgun in public for self-defense and that modern regulations must be consistent with the nation’s historical tradition of firearm regulation. The “sensitive places” exception has long been recognized for a few traditional locations such as schools, government buildings, and polling places. The question in cases like Novotny is how far states may expand that exception.
Maryland’s list includes public demonstrations and nearby areas, mass transit, restaurants and bars that serve alcohol, museums, stadiums, amusement parks, healthcare facilities, and large areas of state parks and forests. Challengers argued that the combined effect leaves law-abiding permit holders with few practical places to carry. The state argued that each category fits within historical traditions of regulating firearms where large numbers of people gather or where special safety concerns exist.
Thomas noted that similar expansions have appeared in other states. He listed examples such as New York (roughly 20 categories), California (roughly 29 categories), and additional lists in Illinois and Hawaii. He wrote that the cumulative result in some places is to prohibit firearms “wherever people gather for eating, drinking, recreation, amusement, and free speech,” which he described as an affront to the right of law-abiding citizens. Expanding sensitive places to cover every public gathering, he added, would eviscerate the general right to carry for self-defense.
How Both Sides Read the Statement
Gun-rights organizations that brought or supported the Maryland case said they were disappointed the Court declined review but encouraged by Thomas’s language. Bill Sack of the Second Amendment Foundation noted that the group has a narrower challenge already pending that focuses on public parks in New York. Groups such as the Firearms Policy Coalition have argued for years that some states are using the sensitive-places label to recreate the kind of broad carry bans that Bruen rejected.
Supporters of the Maryland law and similar measures in other states point out that Thomas himself agreed the Court should not take this particular case. They note that the Fourth Circuit and other lower courts have so far found historical analogues for many of the restrictions. They also argue that legislatures retain room to protect places where crowds gather, children are present, or alcohol is served. The denial of review leaves those lower-court decisions in force and does not create new binding precedent on the scope of sensitive places.
Readers can weigh Thomas’s historical doubts against the fact that he joined the denial and against the continuing existence of the Fourth Circuit ruling. The statement is not a merits decision. It is a public signal that at least one justice wants a cleaner vehicle to test how far the sensitive-places doctrine can stretch after Bruen.
The Larger Second Amendment Landscape
The Maryland denial arrives while the Court has other firearm cases on its calendar. Oral arguments are expected in December on challenges to state bans on certain semiautomatic rifles often called assault weapons. The Trump administration has filed a brief supporting the position that governments cannot categorically ban firearms that are in common use by law-abiding citizens for lawful purposes.
Earlier in 2026 the Court ruled 9-0 that a habitual marijuana user could not be automatically barred from owning a firearm under the facts of that case. Planet Today reported the decision here: US Supreme Court Backs Gun Ownership by Marijuana Users in 9-0 Landmark Ruling.
Thomas authored the majority opinion in Bruen. He has repeatedly written that lower courts in jurisdictions with strict gun laws have been slow to apply the historical test the Court set out. In earlier denials involving Maryland’s assault-weapons ban he dissented and said the Court should not wait to decide whether the most popular rifle in the country can be banned. His November 16 statement continues that pattern: he accepts the procedural decision not to take a messy case while putting states on notice that broader challenges may not last forever.
What Happens Next
Maryland’s restrictions stay in effect. Other states with similar lists continue to enforce them. Challengers are likely to file narrower suits that isolate one or two categories—such as parks, transit, or restaurants—so the Court can examine a single historical tradition at a time. Thomas’s statement gives those future petitions a clearer path if at least three other justices agree the question is ready.
Whether the Court will grant such a case remains uncertain. The justices have turned away several gun cases since Bruen while accepting others. Public opinion, crime data, and the political composition of state legislatures will continue to shape what laws are passed and which ones reach the high court. For now, the public record shows a denial of review, a statement of skepticism from one justice, and an open invitation for a better-framed challenge.
Primary Sources and Further Reading
- Supreme Court docket for Novotny v. Moore: No. 25-1324
- Justice Thomas’s statement (PDF): Statement respecting the denial of certiorari
- Gateway Pundit report: Justice Clarence Thomas Puts Democrat-Controlled States on Notice
- Fourth Circuit decision upholding most of the Maryland restrictions (January 2026)
- New York State Rifle & Pistol Association v. Bruen (2022)
- Coverage from Maryland Matters, The Hill, CBS News, and Newsweek (November 16–17, 2026)
Original source: The Gateway Pundit, November 16, 2026 – Justice Clarence Thomas Puts Democrat-Controlled States on Notice Over Sweeping Gun Bans After Supreme Court Declines Maryland Second Amendment Challenge. Primary documents from the U.S. Supreme Court.
Disclaimer for fact-checkers: This article reports on the Supreme Court’s denial of certiorari in Novotny v. Moore and the accompanying statement by Justice Clarence Thomas, both available on the Court’s official website. It also draws from contemporaneous reporting by multiple outlets. The statement is not a majority opinion and does not change the law. Readers should consult the primary PDF and docket. Gateway Pundit is a conservative news site; other sources include mainstream outlets such as The Hill and CBS News.
Original article: Justice Thomas Signals Doubts on Maryland Gun-Free Zones on Planet Today 🚀
Automatically republished from the main blog.
